discuss how the court decided the issue(s);

Women Legal StudiesBoth cases can be found at the Supreme Court of Canada decisions website at the links given below. You can find hard copies of the case in any library which carries law reporters.InstructionsFor this assignment keep your case comment simple. Your case comment will be complete if you do the following things:1.state the issue or issues that are the focus of the comment;2.mention whatever facts are necessary to give context to the issue(s);3.discuss how the court decided the issue(s);4.discuss (briefly) any wider implications of the decision that you can determine;5.provide a final closing comment on whether you agree with the courts decision and give the reasons why.Your case comment doesnt need to follow the exact order of the components above. Depending on your argument a different ordering may promote a better logical flow. However if you do follow the order above your case comment will be reasonably wellorganized.Make sure that you really understand the issue(s). The best way to do that is to read the case many times. Read the entire case even if you only discuss one issue among many.Your ability to write clearly and correctly is critical and will heavily affect your mark. Use simple language short(er) sentences and precise words.A good strategy is to read your argument aloud. If it sounds confusing or unclear it will come across that way to the reader.Case 1Newfoundland (Treasury Board) v. NAPE [2004] 3 S.C.R. 381In 1988 the government of Newfoundland and Labrador signed a Pay Equity Agreement in favour of female employees in the health care sector which included those represented in collective bargaining by the appellant union.In 1991 the same government introduced the Public Sector Restraint Act which deferred the commencement of the promised pay equity increase (section 9) from 1988 to 1991 and extinguished the 19881991 arrears. Section 9 effectively erased the Provinces obligation to pay out approximately $24 million. The justification was that the government was experiencing a financial crisis unprecedented in the Provinces history. The government adopted other severe measures to reduce the Provinces deficit including a freeze on wage scales for public sector employees a closure of hospital beds and a freeze on per capita student grants and equalization grants to school boards. It also laid off almost two thousand employees and terminated publiclyfunded medical care coverage for certain items. Grievances were filed on behalf of some female employees affected by the cut to pay equity. The Arbitration Board ordered the government to comply with the original terms of the Pay Equity Agreement holding that section 9 of the Act infringed section 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and that the infringement could not be justified under section 1. On judicial review the motions judge quashed the Boards decision and dismissed the grievances. He agreed that section 9 infringed section 15(1) but found the infringement justifiable under section 1. The Court of Appeal upheld the motions judges decision. One appeal judge suggested that explicit recognition of the separation of powers doctrine should be added to the section 1 test. The case was further appealed to the Supreme Court of Canada which is the decision referenced for this assignment.Case 2Trociuk v. British Columbia (A.G.) [2003] 1 S.C.R. 835The appellant and the respondent in this case are the estranged father and mother of triplets. The mother (the appellant) filled out and submitted the statement of live birth on her own and marked the father (the respondent) as unacknowledged by the mother. She alone chose and registered the childrens surname pursuant to sections 3(1)(b) and 4(1)(a) of the British Columbia Vital Statistics Act. Under section 3(6)(b) of the Act the father is precluded from altering the registration. Accordingly the Director of Vital Statistics refused both of the fathers requests to have the birth registration forms amended to include his identity. The British Columbia Supreme Court dismissed the fathers request for a declaration that the legislation violates section 15(1) of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. The Court of Appeal in a majority judgment upheld that decision. The decision referenced for this assignment comes from the Supreme Court of Canada.


The post discuss how the court decided the issue(s); appeared first on Term Paper Tutors.

"Do you need a similar assignment done for you from scratch? We have qualified writers to help you with a guaranteed plagiarism-free A+ quality paper. Discount Code: SUPER50!"

order custom paper


Submit Paper Details
Top Grade AssignmentsIssue instructions for your paper in the order form. Include a discount code if you have one. Your account will be created automatically.

Make Your Payment

Top Grade AssignmentsYour payment is processed by a secure system. We accept PayPal, MasterCard, Visa, Amex, and Discover.

The Writing Process
Top Grade AssignmentsCommunicate with your writer, clarify all the questions with our support team, upload all the necessary files for the writer to use.

Download Completed Paper

Top Grade AssignmentsCheck your paper if it meets your requirements, the editable version. If any changes are needed, send the order for revision.

Important Legal Notice

Using this service is LEGAL and IS NOT prohibited by any university/college policies. You are allowed to use our model academic papers in one of the following ways:

  • To gain additional knowledge about the topic;
  • To refer to the paper as a source of ideas and reasoning, given that appropriate references are provided;
  • To paraphrase the ideas contained in the paper (refer to your school’s policy on plagiarism and academic honesty);
  • To use it for direct citing, given that appropriate references are provided.
Need help with your assignment?

We help students with well-written, original essays before the deadlines.
With more than 50,000 orders completed successfully for students around the world, count on us for your academic needs.

We have a team of professional writers, with vast background knowledge, who follow your specific order details and requirements to complete any writing task you need.

The papers written by our professionals can be used as examples, reference sources, or starting points for more research.


Improve your grades
  • Free bibliography page
  • Free outline
  • 915+ certified ENL and ESL writers to choose from
  • Original, fully referenced and formatted writing
  • On-time delivery, or you get a refund
  • Writer is fully qualified in your area of study
  • Writer has your degree level or higher
  • Communicate with your essay writer, a true academic expert, directly
  • Unlimited revision requests within 14 days
  • Plagiarism report to make sure the work is 100% plagiarism free
  • 24/7 instant support by phone, live chat, email, and messaging
Top Grade Assignments
Top Grade Assignments

© 2021 Topgradeassignments.org provides writing and research services for limited use only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references and in accordance with Terms & Conditions.