writing peer review 2

Problem Description Peer Review Tips

In reviewing peers’ work, it is important to strike a balance between offering broad comments about the

paper’s content and specific comments about the writing style. Sometimes, focusing too much attention

to issues of grammar and word choice can divert attention away from the overall content of a paper.

Similarly, too much attention on the overall content can sometimes prevent the reviewer from making

important comments about the writing clarity. When approaching the peer review, balance your

attention between the overall content and specific writing issues.

It is often helpful to praise what works well in the draft before addressing what’s missing. So, try to

begin your comments with a positive note. For example, you might say, “Your paper clearly describes

the division in the parliament of Northern Ireland. However, you bring up a lot of background about the

broader conflict (for example, the British colonization of Ireland) that isn’t directly relevant. It would be

helpful to give more information about the different parties in the N Ireland parliament. What

constituents do these parties represent? Why do people support certain parties?”

It can be helpful to read the paper first for content. Try to understand the larger issues first. The

problem description should very clearly accomplish the following:

Define a specific problem related to the conflict case.

The writer should NOT identify the

question of statehood as the problem. For example, the writer’s problem should not be the

question of whether Palestine or Abkhazia should be an independent state. Similarly, the writer

should not address whether Northern Ireland should be part of the United Kingdom or the

Republic of Ireland or whether Nagorno Karabakh should be part of Azerbaijan or Armenia.

Describe the current context of the problem.

It should be clear what caused the particular

problem and how the problem is related to the greater conflict. For example, a student writing

about the economic consequences of the Gaza blockade should clearly describe why there is a

blockade on Gaza and how the Gaza blockade relates to the broader conflict between Israelis

and Palestinians.


The writer should NOT use the problem description section to describe the history of

the conflict. For example, a writer describing the Gaza blockade should not include

details about the colonial roots of the Israel-Palestine conflict. The details about the

broader conflict should directly relate to the problem at hand.

Convince the reader that the problem requires attention.

The writer should clearly describe the

consequences of the problem in order to convince the reader that the problem needs to be

addressed. For example, a student writing about polarization in the N Ireland parliament should

explain how the polarization affects the potential for violence to resume in N Ireland.

Build a framework from which the policy options can be argued.

The policy option section will

follow the problem description section. Each of the policy options will aim to resolve the same

particular problem, but they will aim to solve the problem in different ways. By the end of the

problem description section, it should be very clear which single problem the policy options will

aim to resolve.

After reading the draft, respond to the following questions:

What is the specific problem addressed?

What caused the particular problem and how does it relate to the broader conflict case?

Is there background information that’s not directly relevant to the problem at hand? What other

information do I need to understand the problem instead of the background details presented?

Why is the problem important? What are the consequences of the problem?

After I finish reading the problem description, I’ll read the policy options section. Do I know

what problem each of the policy options will tackle?

On the whole, what are the greatest strengths of the paper?

Where should the writer focus his/her energies on revising the problem description?

If you don’t know the answer to any of these questions, then let the writer know what’s unclear. Be sure

that your comments are specific. So, don’t just say, “I don’t know what particular problem is addressed.”

Instead, say, “Your paper talks a lot about the violence in the conflict, but it would be helpful to focus

your description more on a particular issue. What specific problem would you like to address regarding

violence? You address perpetual violations to ceasefire agreements, the sale of weapons, the use of land

mines and other weapons that allow indiscriminate killing, and lack of transparency in investigating

human rights abuses. Which one would you like to focus on in the paper?”

Once you offer broad comments about the paper’s content, then re-read the paper and offer some

suggestions about the writing clarity. You can note the following:

Instances of poor word choice

Complicated sentence structure

Sentences that are too long

Paragraphs that are too long

Paragraphs that lack a coherent flow from one sentence to the next and a clear topic sentence

Grammar errors

Comments about writing style are best made in the text (as opposed to at the end of the text). So, don’t

leave a comment at the end indicating that there are many grammatical errors in the paper; instead,

make a note in the text pointing to specific grammatical errors. In your note, explain “There’s an issue

with subject-verb agreement here.” Alternatively, you can correct the grammar error.

Because this is a writing class, it’s important for the writing to be very clear and concise. So, please be

sure to devote enough time and attention to commenting on your peer’s writing style. Writing is

difficult. Everyone can improve their writing. So, your review should have some comments about

shortcomings in your peer’s writing.

You should submit both your in-text comments about your peer’s writing style and your answers to

the questions at the top of the second page to your peer through Canvas and to the Canvas Peer

Review assignment folder. Thus, you should submit two documents to two places


Do you need a similar assignment done for you from scratch? We have qualified writers to help you. We assure you an A+ quality paper that is free from plagiarism. Order now for an Amazing Discount!
Use Discount Code “Newclient” for a 15% Discount!

NB: We do not resell papers. Upon ordering, we do an original paper exclusively for you.

Top Grade Assignments

The post writing peer review 2 appeared first on Custom Nursing Help.

"Do you need a similar assignment done for you from scratch? We have qualified writers to help you with a guaranteed plagiarism-free A+ quality paper. Discount Code: SUPER50!"

order custom paper


Submit Paper Details
Top Grade AssignmentsIssue instructions for your paper in the order form. Include a discount code if you have one. Your account will be created automatically.

Make Your Payment

Top Grade AssignmentsYour payment is processed by a secure system. We accept PayPal, MasterCard, Visa, Amex, and Discover.

The Writing Process
Top Grade AssignmentsCommunicate with your writer, clarify all the questions with our support team, upload all the necessary files for the writer to use.

Download Completed Paper

Top Grade AssignmentsCheck your paper if it meets your requirements, the editable version. If any changes are needed, send the order for revision.

Important Legal Notice

Using this service is LEGAL and IS NOT prohibited by any university/college policies. You are allowed to use our model academic papers in one of the following ways:

  • To gain additional knowledge about the topic;
  • To refer to the paper as a source of ideas and reasoning, given that appropriate references are provided;
  • To paraphrase the ideas contained in the paper (refer to your school’s policy on plagiarism and academic honesty);
  • To use it for direct citing, given that appropriate references are provided.
Need help with your assignment?

We help students with well-written, original essays before the deadlines.
With more than 50,000 orders completed successfully for students around the world, count on us for your academic needs.

We have a team of professional writers, with vast background knowledge, who follow your specific order details and requirements to complete any writing task you need.

The papers written by our professionals can be used as examples, reference sources, or starting points for more research.


Improve your grades
  • Free bibliography page
  • Free outline
  • 915+ certified ENL and ESL writers to choose from
  • Original, fully referenced and formatted writing
  • On-time delivery, or you get a refund
  • Writer is fully qualified in your area of study
  • Writer has your degree level or higher
  • Communicate with your essay writer, a true academic expert, directly
  • Unlimited revision requests within 14 days
  • Plagiarism report to make sure the work is 100% plagiarism free
  • 24/7 instant support by phone, live chat, email, and messaging
Top Grade Assignments
Top Grade Assignments

© 2021 Topgradeassignments.org provides writing and research services for limited use only. All the materials from our website should be used with proper references and in accordance with Terms & Conditions.